loaderimg
What
image
  • imageAnimal Care & Services
  • imageAuthors, Speakers & Public Figures
  • imageAutomotive & Marine
  • imageBreweries, Wineries & Bars
  • imageBusiness Services & Supplies
  • imageConstruction & Contractors
  • imageEducation
  • imageEntertainment, Recreation & Events
  • imageFood, Beverage & Catering
  • imageHealth & Wellness
  • imageHome & Garden
  • imageHome Services & Repairs
  • imageLegal, Financial & Insurance
  • imageManufacturing, Agriculture Wholesale
  • imageMedia, Marketing & Photography
  • imageNonprofits & Social Services
  • imagePersonal Care & Services
  • imageReal Estate & Moving
  • imageRestaurants, Coffee Shops & Bakeries
  • imageRetail, Art, Collectibles, Gifts
  • imageTechnology & IT Services
  • imageTravel, Lodging & Transportation
Where
image
image

Rolling Pin Bakehouse enjoys allowing customers to easily produce our gourmet pies in their very own kitchen! In 2012 I started selling homemade pies on our gravel road and at local farmers markets. The sugar cream pie, which is a secret family recipe, was by far our best seller.

My husband had a brilliant idea to create a pie filling mix that would be simple & convenient for customers to make on their own. So, I got to work… After a year of trial and error, I finally mastered the perfect gourmet pie mix for customers to enjoy!

You just add a couple of simple ingredients to our gourmet pie mixes, and you have a decadent dessert that tastes just like the pies customers have been enjoying all these years.

The gourmet pie mixes make for a unique gift idea as well!

Available in our signature Sugar Cream Pie, Chocolate Cream Pie,Chocolate Chip Pie and Pumpkin Spice Cream Pie flavors. All cream pie varieties are gluten free.

Rolling Pin Bakehouse

Average Rating: 4.9 / 5 (26 Reviews)

image

Lois Stogdill

1 Review

Rolling Pin Bakehouse

5/ 5

My husband’s favorite pie is rhubarb. We are so fortunate to have found this local micro bakery. We pre ordered these pies for my husband’s Birthday and they did not disappoint! My husband said “this is the best rhubarb pie I’ve ever had”!!! My...

×

My husband’s favorite pie is rhubarb. We are so fortunate to have found this local micro bakery. We pre ordered these pies for my husband’s Birthday and they did not disappoint! My husband said “this is the best rhubarb pie I’ve ever had”!!! My children are not rhubarb pie fans, after trying this one they now love it. The pies were not overly sweet and tart. The baker Natalie’s father grows the rhubarb. The pie crust was excellent. Highly recommend this small local bakery! They even sell Indiana’s famous sugar cream pie. Thank you Rolling Pin Bakehouse!!!

image

Sean Peterson

1 Review

Rolling Pin Bakehouse

4/ 5

Loved their cinnamon rolls! Their dinner rolls were pretty good too. We also tried their peach-sugar cream pie. It was a little light on peaches, but otherwise tasty.

image

Brittney Zent

1 Review

Rolling Pin Bakehouse

5/ 5

Rolling Pin Bakehouse has the best pies my family has ever had! We have tried the Tollhouse, Sugar Cream, Pecan, Cherry, Apple, and Buckeye so far and each one is amazing! My family now ask for pie instead of cake for their birthdays!

×

Rolling Pin Bakehouse has the best pies my family has ever had! We have tried the Tollhouse, Sugar Cream, Pecan, Cherry, Apple, and Buckeye so far and each one is amazing! My family now ask for pie instead of cake for their birthdays!

image

Linda Schusterll

1 Review

Rolling Pin Bakehouse

5/ 5

There peanut butter pie and sugar cream pie are wonderful! For Christmas we tried the cinnamon rolls and they were amazing. Orders are filled right on time with a big smile! Great bakery and great service! Linda S.

×

There peanut butter pie and sugar cream pie are wonderful! For Christmas we tried the cinnamon rolls and they were amazing. Orders are filled right on time with a big smile! Great bakery and great service! Linda S.

image

Vanessa Hart

1 Review

Rolling Pin Bakehouse

5/ 5

I ordered the caramels and raspberry half moons over Christmas. YUMMY! The caramels were the perfect texture/consistency and got eaten up in a day. My in-laws loved them too. I've tried most of her breads and some of the cookies, have...

×

I ordered the caramels and raspberry half moons over Christmas. YUMMY! The caramels were the perfect texture/consistency and got eaten up in a day. My in-laws loved them too. I've tried most of her breads and some of the cookies, have yet to find anything from this bakery that I don't enjoy :-)

image